Stop by and check out Jim's Picks - a fun selection of interesting and unique items!
Click above or text "Menu" to (716) 226-5559 to order by text.
Your NEW Traditional favorite grocery store!
As a locally-owned store, we understand the importance of supporting local businesses, and carry several products produced around Western New York. Stop into the store to try some for yourself!
Locally Grown Produce
Every week, we purchase locally grown produce from a local produce auction. Stop by to pick up fresh tomatoes, zucchinis, yellow squash, peas, and more!
Sprague's Maple Syrup
Sprague's pure, grade A maple syrup is offered in a variety of sizes, and comes directly from their maple farm in Portville, New York!
We carry several types of cheese from the Cuba Cheese Shoppe, including cheese curds, cheese spreads, blocks of cheese, and more.
Swatt's Bakery is locally owned and bakes their bread in Olean, New York. Stop in to try their trademark L.A. Cinnamon bread!
Angee's Classic Spaghetti Sauce
Jim's Park & Shop carries Angee's Classic Spaghetti Sauce, made with the original recipe from 1948, and used in many of the restaurant's dishes.
We carry several brands of pure, natural honey from local farms around Western New York, including Goldenrod Hollow Farm in Fillmore, the Milestone Apiary in Farmersville Station, and S & C Farm in Cuba.
Beer from Local Breweries
Jim's Park & Shop carries several kinds of beer from local breweries. Four Mile Brewing is Olean's first brewery in almost 100 years, Ellicottville Brewing Company offers several flavors of craft beer, and Southern Tier Brewing Company, though based in Lakewood, New York, has a growing influence in Pennsylvania and Ohio!
Stearns Barbecue Sauce
Made in Alfred Station, New York, Stearns Barbecue Sauce allows you to get that famous New York State Fireman's chicken barbecue flavor at home! Good on chicken, pork, beef, and more, this sauce will be perfect for your next barbecue!
Marble Farms Eggs
Marble Farms produces farm fresh, pasture-raised eggs laid by all vegetarian, free range chickens. These eggs are free from the effects of chemical additives and antibiotics in the diets of the chickens that lay them, and are local as well!
McCullagh Coffee Roasters
Based in Buffalo, New York, McCullagh Coffee Roasters uses sustainably-sourced coffee from Rainforest Alliance Certified farms. They also offer k-cup pods in a variety of flavors, which are sold in-store too!
Majestic Hill Coffee Roasters
Majestic Hill Coffee Roasters is based in Castile, New York, and offers artisan coffee in a variety of flavors, made with 100% arabica beans. Check it out at our specialty coffee stand!